2023-24 Kevin Dunigan (Logan Hocking Times & BMG Media) & Ken Smith (WRAC/C103)
2022-23 Mark Carpenter (Adams County Public Defender), Danny Dodds (WVNU - Greenfield), Chuck Greenslate (WNXT - Portsmouth),
Mark Williams (WNXT - Portsmouth), Derrick Webb (Southern Ohio Sports Authority - SOSA), and Kevin Wiseman (Athens Messenger)
2021-22 None
2020-21 None
2019-20 Tom Beard (WKKJ - Chillicothe), Dale Hamilton (WNXT - Portsmouth), and Phil Gray (Chillicothe Gazette)
2018-19 None
2017-18 None
2016-17 Mark Hunter (WATH - Athens), Kent Sanborn, and Tony Shotsky
2015-16 None
2014-15 None
2013-14 None
2012-13 None
2011-12 None
2010-11 None
2009-10 Don Bowles (WRAC - West Union)
2008-09 Bill Robinson (Marietta Times), Dan Dobbins (WKOV - Jackson), and Dan Morrow (WKOV - Jackson)
2007-08 Craig Dunn (Logan Daily News) and Dan Ramey (WKKJ - Chillicothe)
2006-07 Pete Wilson (Jackson County Telegram) and John Wharff (WMOA - Marietta)
2005-06 Roger Gray (WNXT - Portsmouth)
2004-05 Harold “Buzz” Fisher (Jackson Times Journal and WKOV- Jackson) and Joe Edwards (WAIS and WSEO - Nelsonville)
2003-04 Bob Willis (WKOV - Jackson and Wellston Telegram) and Dave Harris (Pomeroy Daily Sentinel)
2002-03 None
2001-02 None
2000-01 Randy Heath (Jackson) and Larry Herges (WATH/WXTQ - Athens)
1999-00 Jim Myers (Logan Daily News) and Ernie Blankenship (WSRW - Hillsboro)
1998-99 Hobert Wilson Jr. (Gallipolis Daily Tribune) and Mike Smith (WKKJ/WBEX - Chillicothe)
1997-98 Tom Metters (Athens Messenger) and Jim Smith (WNXT - Portsmouth)